Skip to content
The Pros and Cons of Direct-to-Film Printing vs. Direct-to-Garment Printing for Apparel

The Pros and Cons of Direct-to-Film Printing vs. Direct-to-Garment Printing for Apparel

You don't need us to tell you that the competition between decorated-apparel shops continues to grow, so staying ahead of the curve is a must, not a maybe for screen printers and embroiderers.

Two popular methods making waves in the industry are direct-to-film (DTF) printing and direct-to-garment (DTG) printing. Each method offers unique advantages and presents specific challenges. Understanding these can help you make an informed choice for the decorating methods you offer to clients in your shop.

A Look at Direct-to-Film Printing

First, here are the pros of this newer decorating method:

1. Versatility: DTF transfers can be applied to a variety of fabrics, including cotton, polyester, blends, and even non-textile substrates like nylon. This makes it a flexible choice for diverse projects.

2. Vibrant colors: DTF transfers produce bright, vibrant prints with excellent color reproduction. The ability to use white ink under base ensures designs pop on dark fabrics.

3. Durability: The prints you can create with DTF are highly durable, often outperforming traditional DTG prints in terms of wash and wear resistance.

4. No pre-treatment needed: Unlike DTG, DTF printing does not require pre-treating the garment, saving time and reducing the potential for mistakes.

5. Cost-effective for smaller runs: DTF is particularly cost-effective for short runs or one-off designs since it does not require setup time or screens.

Now, here are some of the considerations for DTF printing, if you're producing the transfers yourself and applying them in-house. 

1. Learning curve: There's a learning curve associated with DTF printing, particularly in perfecting the transfer process and managing the adhesive powder application.

2. Equipment cost: The initial investment in DTF equipment and supplies can be higher compared to traditional screen-printing setups.

3. Complex workflow: The DTF process involves multiple steps, including printing, applying adhesive powder, and curing, which can be more time-consuming compared to DTG.

A Look at Direct-to-Garment Printing

First, here are some reasons why many shops offer DTG printing.

1. High detail and quality: DTG printing excels in producing high-detail, photo-quality prints directly onto garments, making it ideal for intricate designs and small text.

2. Ease of use: DTG printers are user-friendly and require minimal setup, allowing you to offer a quick production turnaround, which is great for on-demand printing.

3. No transfers needed: With DTG, you print the design is printed directly onto the garment, eliminating the need for transfer sheets or adhesive powders.

4. Soft hand feel: DTG prints have a soft feel, blending seamlessly with the fabric, which consumers often prefer for fashion-forward apparel.

Here are some of the reasons why DTG isn't always the right choice for an order.

1. Fabric limitations: DTG works best on 100% cotton and cotton blends. Printing on polyester or other synthetic fabrics can result in subpar quality.

2. Pre-treatment required: Most DTG processes require pre-treating the garment, which adds an extra step and potential for error with the final print.

3. Higher cost for bigger runs: For large production runs, DTG can be more expensive compared to screen printing due to ink costs and slower printing speeds.

4. Maintenance: DTG printers require regular maintenance to prevent clogging and ensure consistent print quality, which can be time-consuming.

Making the Right Choice for Your Decorated-Apparel Shop

When deciding between DTF and DTG printing, consider the following factors:

1. Project type: For high-detail, small-run, and on-demand projects, DTG is often the best choice. For versatility across fabric types and cost-effectiveness for short runs, DTF stands out.

2. Investment: Evaluate your budget for new equipment. While DTF may require a higher initial investment, it can offer greater versatility and durability.

3. Workflow: Consider the complexity and time involved in each process. If your shop can manage the multi-step DTF process, the benefits may outweigh the initial learning curve.

Starting with DTF: Outsourcing vs. In-House Production

A strategic approach to incorporating DTF into your business is to start by outsourcing your DTF transfers. This allows you to test the quality and suitability of DTF prints for your shop and clients without the upfront investment in equipment. By working with a reliable DTF transfer provider, you can gauge the market demand and see firsthand how DTF prints hold up in real-world use.

Once you determine that DTF works well for your business, investing in your own DTF printer can offer greater flexibility. Bringing the process in-house means you control the timing of creating transfers, which is particularly beneficial for print-on-demand services and other time-sensitive setups. This transition allows you to scale up your operations and offer more customized solutions to your clients.

Ready to Take the DTF Leap?

At Arcus Printers, we understand the importance of making an informed decision. Investing in the right technology can elevate your business, improve your product offerings, and expand your market reach. 

If you’re interested in exploring DTF printing further, we’re here to help. Contact us for more information, equipment options, and support to get started with this innovative printing method.

Cart 0

Your cart is currently empty.

Start Shopping